Dairy, Cheese, & Eggs

Gibbs Cheese Cheddar - Medium-Sharp New York State Cheddar

From $4.05

Madison's Dale Filbrun Farms Certified Organic Large Eggs

$9.00

Harmony Plant Fare Vegan Chicken Tender Varieties

From $6.00

OTR Bagel Bar Fresh Herb Cream Cheese

From $2.20

OTR Bagel Bar Plain Cream Cheese

From $2.20

Gibbs Cheese Butter - Old Fashioned Tub Butter

From $4.30

Grayson's Veggie Breakfast Patties

$11.99

Gibbs Cheese Land O'Lakes Yellow American Cheese

$3.50

Gibbs Cheese Cheddar - Mild, New York State cheddar Cheese

From $3.75

Madison's Snowville Creamery Milk

$7.05

Gibbs Cheese Colby Jack-Marble Colby

From $3.75

The Rhined Prairie Breeze

From $6.75

Gibbs Cheese Whipped Garlic Butter

From $2.60

The Rhined Rhined Pimento Cheese

$7.00

Gibbs Cheese Swiss Ohio's Best Amish

From $5.35

Gibbs Cheese Garlic Cheddar

From $5.90

Gibbs Cheese Habanero-Jalapeño Cheddar - Yancey's Fancy Brand

From $6.60

Harmony Plant Fare Seitan Ham

From $8.00

The Rhined 24-Month Parmigiano Reggiano

From $8.25

Gibbs Cheese Mozzarella - Whole-Milk

From $3.55

Dean's Mediterranean Imports Feta Cheese

From $3.00

Grayson's Black Bean Burgers

From $1.70

Gibbs Cheese Havarti Butter Cheese Denmark

$7.00

Madison's Shredded Cheeses, Dairy Fresh

$3.55

Harmony Plant Fare Garden Vegan Cream Cheese

From $5.00

OTR Bagel Bar Chive Cream Cheese

From $2.20

The Rhined Trillium

From $10.00

OTR Bagel Bar Strawberry Cream Cheese

From $2.25

Gibbs Cheese Parmesan - Domestic Fine Grated

From $7.00

Gibbs Cheese Colby, Mild

From $3.75

OTR Bagel Bar Jalapeño Cream Cheese

From $2.20

Madison's Sour Cream

$2.50

The Rhined Rhined Mini

$31.00

Gibbs Cheese Provolone

$3.75

Gibbs Cheese Amish Baby Swiss Guggisberg

From $4.65

Gibbs Cheese Ricotta, WHIPPED, WHOLE MILK

From $3.20

Grayson's Amish Pepperjack Cheddar

From $5.00

The Rhined Pleasant Ridge Reserve

From $8.00

Gibbs Cheese Hot Pepper Cheese

From $4.30

Grayson's Land O'Lakes American Cheese

From $5.00

Gibbs Cheese Reggiano Parmesan Italy

From $12.40

Gibbs Cheese Mozzarella, Fresh Cilliegene

From $5.20

Gibbs Cheese Burrata Cheese

$5.10

Grayson's Amish Hot Habanero

From $7.00

Gibbs Cheese Swiss - German

From $5.90

Gibbs Cheese Pecorino Romano - Italy

From $10.25

Harmony Plant Fare Plain Vegan Cream Cheese

From $5.00

Gibbs Cheese Smoked Cheddar

From $6.20